Pet Insurance Blog

Can You Have More Than One Cat Insurance Policy?

Kari Steere
Licensed Insurance Producer - Pawlicy Advisor
multiple pet cats in house

Veterinary costs can easily reach thousands of dollars, and if your four-legged friend needs medical care, it can seriously impact your family finances. With that in mind, having two insurance policies could put you in a good position in case your pet gets sick or injured, and you need to make a claim.

But is it even possible to have more than one insurance policy for your pet? And, more importantly, is it legal to make the same claim with two providers? This article will provide pet owners with the answers to these questions and provide more information related to multiple insurance policies.

Here are answers to a few common questions we receive about whether you can have more than one cat insurance policy:

Is it possible to insure your cat twice?

The answer is yes, pet owners can sign up their pet for two different insurance policies. However, just like with human health insurance, having multiple pet health insurance policies doesn’t mean you will get reimbursed twice for the cost of a vet visit. If you pay for a covered expense out-of-pocket — such as diagnostic tests, treatment of an illness, emergency surgery for an injury, prescription drugs, or any other condition that insurance payout, you are only allowed to make a claim on one of the pet insurance policies.

Making a claim with two insurance companies is considered a fraud.

Typically, when filling in a claim form, you will be asked if you have any other insurance policies. If you have more than one pet health insurance policy and you fail to mention it, you’re providing the insurance provider with fraudulent information. This could result in your current and any future claims being disapproved.

Is it legal to have more than one pet insurance policy?

No, insuring your dog or cat twice is not illegal, so long as you don’t make a claim for the same incident with both providers.

However, having multiple policies is not recommended.

First, you will need to pay two monthly premiums for two different policies and you can only make one claim. Second, having multiple pet health insurance policies could cause problems if you need to make a claim.

Many insurance policy documents state that if they discover that you have multiple policies, they’ll refuse to pay your claim. Therefore, if both insurers come to this knowledge, there’s a risk you won’t be able to make a claim with either of them.

For instance, some pet owners decide to overlap policies when they’re with another pet insurance provider in order to ensure their pets will be covered during the waiting period. The length of the waiting period before the new pet health insurance policy takes effect depends on the pet insurance company.

Some companies like PetFirst provide accident coverage as soon as the next day, while others (like Hartville Pet Insurance, ASPCA Pet Health Insurance, and Nationwide) require customers to wait 14 days for accidents before the coverage kicks in. On the other hand, most companies require customers to wait 14 to 15 days depending on their illness coverage.

If you make a claim with your old insurance provider during this overlap period, the new insurance company might treat the condition that was claimed for as a pre-existing condition, which means that this condition won’t be covered for the rest of the policy.

Pro Tip: Compare waiting periods for top insurance providers to get a general idea of how long your pet friend might need to go unprotected by the end of your existing pet insurance coverage before the new policy takes effect.

Do I have to cancel my cat insurance policy before switching providers?

No, you don't have to cancel your cat insurance policy before getting a new plan. Most policies require a 14-day waiting period before the policy goes into effect and you can file a claim. If you were to cancel before your new coverage kicked in, you could be unprotected from financial risk.

In this case, you're allowed to have two cat insurance policies, but keep in mind that you'll need to pay for both premiums while your old policy remains active. That's why it's generally smart to wait until your policy is due for renewal to switch pet insurance providers. Most insurance policies are renewed automatically every year.

Before switching providers, talk to your current company first and express the changes you'd like. In some cases, you might be able to adjust your plan while staying with the same provider to prevent any loss in coverage or paying for more than one policy at once.

If you do switch mid-term and temporarily have two cat insurance policies, don't forget to cancel your old plan once your new coverage kicks in. Stopping your automatic payments will not cancel the policy; you'll still be responsible for the monthly premiums for the remainder of the policy term, as well as any applicable late fees incurred.

Pro Tip: The Pawlicy Advisor search tool can help you pick a great cat insurance plan with comprehensive coverage from the start. That way, you won't have to question signing up for an extra policy or switching providers after you enroll.

Key Takeaways

  • Insuring your pet twice is perfectly legal, as long as you don’t claim for the same thing with both pet insurance companies.
  • However, having more than one pet insurance policy isn’t recommended. Not only will you have to pay for two policies but you could also face problems if you need to make a claim.
  • Don’t forget to cancel any existing policy if you’re switching to a new one. If you’re thinking of canceling, it’s best to wait until your policy is due for renewal and then switch.

Do you want to find the best pet insurance?

Let's analyze your pet's breed, age, and location to find the right coverage and the best savings. Ready?

Analyze My Pet

About Pawlicy Advisor

The pet insurance marketplace endorsed by veterinarians, at Pawlicy Advisor we make buying the best pet insurance easier. By comparing personalized coverage and pricing differences we can save you a ton of money, up to 83% in some instances!

Pawlicy Advisor helping a pet parent and their dog find a great deal on insurance

Instantly Compare Pet Insurance Plans

Get Quotes


How Pet Insurance Works

How To Compare Plans

Determine If Pet Insurance Is Worth It

Determine If Wellness Plans Are Worth It

Vet Visit Costs

New Puppy Checklist

Comparison Charts

ASPCA vs. Pets Best

Pets Best vs. Embrace

Embrace vs. Pumpkin

Pumpkin vs. MetLife

More Comparison Charts

Find Your State

New Jersey





New York



More States

Dog Insurance

German Shepherd




English Bulldog

French Bulldog

Great Dane





More Breeds

Kari Steer, Licensed P&C Insurance Agent at Pawlicy Advisor

Kari Steere
Licensed Insurance Producer - Pawlicy Advisor

Kari Steere is a licensed P&C insurance agent in all 50 states and has focused entirely on pet insurance since 2019. As an animal lover with a rescued Terrier named Barry, when she's not helping pet owners find the perfect plan on Pawlicy Advisor, she runs a ranch in Oregon and rehabilitates any animals that come across her path.

More you might like

woman petting cat while working
5 minute read

What Cat Insurance Do You Need? It Depends

couple petting kitten
5 minute read

Bivvy Pet Insurance Review

woman on laptop playing with cat
6 minute read

When To Buy Cat Insurance: A Licensed Agent's Perspective

female kissing puppy on bed
6 minute read

Petco Pet Insurance Review

man petting australian shepherd
2 minute read

SWBC Pet Insurance Review

military couple sits with dog
2 minute read

Armed Forces Pet Insurance Review

girl holds cat's head in hands
5 minute read

PetPremium Pet Insurance Review

family and dog in rv
2 minute read

American Family Pet Insurance Review

get pet insurance through Pawlicy Advisor on
2 minute read

Pawlicy Advisor Announces Partnership with The Zebra

dog with woman on computer
6 minute read

Is Farmers Pet Insurance Good? Here's How It Stacks Up

blue ribbon dog show winner
5 minute read

Is PetPartners Pet Insurance Good? Here's How It Stacks Up

5 minute read

Can You Switch Pet Insurance?

family at vet with dog
9 minute read

Pet Insurance vs Human Health Insurance

family in the kitchen with cat
4 minute read

Is Costco Pet Insurance Good? Here's How It Stacks Up

dog sits at desk with man
5 minute read

Allstate Pet Insurance Review

professional trainer walks dog pack on leash
4 minute read

Spot Pet Insurance Review

man petting golden retriever
5 minute read

Is USAA Pet Insurance Good?

beagle happy to get pet insurance
4 minute read

Liberty Mutual Pet Insurance Review

woman on computer next to dog
6 minute read

NAPHIA Director Kristen Lynch On Pet Insurance Market Penetration

Kitten gets scratch under skin
5 minute read

AKC Pet Insurance Review

Black and orange cat receives pet
5 minute read

Nationwide Pet Insurance Review

Man holding beagle dog
6 minute read

Geico Pet Insurance Review

Chocolate puppy held by owner
5 minute read

Progressive Pet Insurance Review

Pug puppy and young woman
7 minute read

Is Healthy Paws Pet Insurance Good?

Trupanion pet insurance can pay your veterinarian directly. But is it good pet insurance? Here’s what you need to know.
5 minute read

Is Trupanion's Pet Insurance Good?

Man holding new puppy
10 minute read

When's The Best Time to Get Pet Insurance?

Old Beagle dog sitting next to senior woman
9 minute read

Is Pet Assure Any Good? Here's How It Stacks Up

Woman sitting at desk signing paper with dog on lap
9 minute read

When Is Pet Insurance A Great Decision?

Beagle dog waiting
7 minute read

How Soon Does Pet Insurance Take Effect?

Woman hugging black dog with open mouth
8 minute read

Pet Dental Insurance: How to Find the Best Plan

Pawlicy Advisor Team with Logo
4 minute read

Pawlicy Advisor Raised $6.5M To Help Pet Parents Afford Unexpected Veterinary Treatment

Senior boxer dog
7 minute read

Pet Insurance For Older Pets: Is It Worth It?

walmart storefront
8 minute read

Is Walmart Pet Insurance Good? Here’s How It Stacks Up

banfield pet insurance wellness info and review
9 minute read

Banfield Wellness Plan Info & Review: Everything You Need to Know

wagmo wellness info and review
10 minute read

Is Wagmo Pet Insurance Good? Here's How It Stacks Up

Canine Journal vs. Pawlicy Advisor
10 minute read

Canine Journal vs. Pawlicy Advisor: Which is Best For Pet Insurance

dog looking out window
2 minute read

Three Things to Look for When Comparing Pet Insurance Companies

petinsurancereview vs pawlicy advisor pet insurance
10 minute read

PetInsuranceReview vs. Pawlicy Advisor: Which Is Best For Pet Insurance?

Policygenius vs Pawlicy Advisor pet insurance
10 minute read

Policygenius vs. Pawlicy Advisor: Which is Best for Pet Insurance?

lemonade's pet insurance cats and dogs
9 minute read

Is Lemonade's Pet Insurance Good? Here's How It Stacks Up

Happy dog receives affection from owner
13 minute read

Are Pet Wellness Plans Worth It For Routine Care?

Kitten at a veterinary appointment
13 minute read

Is Cat Insurance Worth It? Ask An Expert

happy pet parent loving on her dog
22 minute read

Fascinating Pet Insurance Statistics 2019-2020

Dog at a veterinary clinic
14 minute read

Is Pet Insurance Worth Getting for Your Dog?

Two dogs running happy and healthy
10 minute read

Pet Insurance for More Than One Pet: Multi-Pet Discounts And Strategies

smiling dog
7 minute read

3 Ways To Use Pet Insurance Like A Pro

rescue dog and cat
14 minute read

Pet Insurance For Rescue Dogs (And Cats) - It's Easier Than You Think

cat and dog together outside
17 minute read

How to Get the Best Pet Insurance Plan, No Matter the Provider

dog with loving pet owner
17 minute read

Average Pet Insurance Cost in 2022 by Breed, Age, & State

pet insurance comparison showcase
17 minute read

How To Compare Pet Insurance Plans

Back to Blog
A family with pets that are insured by Pawlicy Advisor
Pawlicy Advisor is the leading independent marketplace for finding the best coverage for your pet at the lowest rate.
Join 2,438,795+ insured dogs and cats across the US.
Get a Quote
Our pet insurance partners
ASPCA Pet Health Insurance Logo
Pets Best Pet Insurance Logo
Embrace Pet Insurance Logo
Pumpkin Pet Insurance Logo
MetLife Pet Insurance Logo
Prudent Pet Insurance Logo